Commercial Insurance Recruiter
Commercial Insurance Jobs & Recruiters in Indianapolis, IN
Midwest Commercial Insurance & Healthcare Liability Specialist Placement
Indianapolis is a significant Midwest commercial insurance market, anchored by a major healthcare sector, a growing technology community, and a strong independent agency tradition. Healthcare liability, commercial P&C, and underwriting are among the most active hiring disciplines in Indianapolis. The Keystone Crossing and Carmel corridors host most commercial insurance activity. SHG recruits across all commercial insurance disciplines in the Indianapolis market.
Indianapolis Salary Insight: Indianapolis commercial insurance salaries are competitive within the Midwest market. Healthcare Liability Underwriters average $82,000–$128,000. Commercial Lines Account Managers earn $58,000–$88,000. Risk management roles in healthcare and corporate sectors command $92,000–$140,000.
Why Indianapolis Insurance Firms Choose SHG
Indianapolis Insurance Market Knowledge
Deep understanding of Indianapolis's commercial insurance hiring environment — salary norms, talent availability, and what agencies, carriers, and MGAs are competing for in this market.
Pre-Built Talent Pipelines
We don't start from zero when you call. Active candidate relationships across Indianapolis mean faster time-to-fill and better quality hires for permanent roles.
Permanent Placement Only
Every search in Indianapolis is direct hire. No temps, no contract-to-perm. Your hire is a full-time, permanent team member — backed by our retention guarantee.
Key Insurance Employers in Indianapolis
Indianapolis hosts carrier regional offices for Travelers, Nationwide, and multiple specialty healthcare insurers, plus a strong independent agency community. Eli Lilly, IU Health, and major healthcare systems drive significant healthcare liability demand.
Commercial Insurance Jobs We Recruit For in Indianapolis
SHG places commercial insurance professionals at all seniority levels in Indianapolis — from account managers and producers to executives and directors. All placements are direct hire, permanent positions. Submit your resume to be considered for Indianapolis openings.
Commercial Insurance Jobs in Indianapolis — FAQ
QWhat commercial insurance jobs are available in Indianapolis, IN?
Indianapolis is a significant Midwest commercial insurance market. SHG recruits for healthcare liability underwriters, commercial lines account managers, risk managers, claims professionals, and agency leaders across the Indianapolis metro.
QWhat do commercial insurance professionals earn in Indianapolis?
Indianapolis commercial insurance salaries are competitive within the Midwest market. Healthcare Liability Underwriters average $82,000–$128,000. Commercial Lines Account Managers earn $58,000–$88,000. Healthcare and specialty lines professionals command $110,000–$150,000 in total compensation.
QWhich insurance companies hire in Indianapolis, IN?
Indianapolis hosts carrier regional offices for Travelers, Nationwide, and multiple specialty healthcare insurers, plus a strong independent agency community. Eli Lilly, IU Health, and major healthcare systems drive significant healthcare liability demand.
Nearby Markets We Also Recruit In
SHG recruits commercial insurance professionals across Indianapolis and all surrounding markets in Indiana. View all Indiana markets →
For Indianapolis Employers
Hire Commercial Insurance Talent in Indianapolis
Looking for a commercial lines account manager, underwriter, claims professional, or insurance executive in Indianapolis? SHG delivers permanent placements — not temps — with a retention guarantee on every search.
Hire in Indianapolis NowFor Indianapolis Candidates
Find a Commercial Insurance Job in Indianapolis
SHG works with top agencies, carriers, and MGAs in Indianapolis to fill permanent commercial insurance positions. If you're in commercial lines, underwriting, claims, risk management, or E&S — we want to hear from you.
Submit Your ResumeAbout SHG — Commercial Insurance Recruiters in Indianapolis, IN
Stone Hendricks Group (SHG) is a national commercial insurance recruiting firm providing permanent placement services exclusively for the insurance industry. We serve Indianapolis agencies, insurance carriers, MGAs, and wholesale brokers with specialist commercial insurance recruiting across commercial lines, P&C, underwriting, claims, risk management, and E&S / surplus lines.
Unlike generalist staffing firms, SHG works exclusively in commercial insurance — meaning our candidate pipelines, market knowledge, and hiring process are purpose-built for insurance organizations in Indianapolis and across Indiana. Every placement is direct hire and permanent, backed by our industry-leading retention guarantee.
Indianapolis Insurance Salary Benchmarks
Indianapolis commercial insurance compensation is competitive with major Midwest markets. Healthcare and specialty lines professionals command $110,000–$150,000 in total compensation.
Free 2026 Salary GuideRecruiting across all of Indiana?
SHG recruits commercial insurance professionals in every major market across Indiana.