Commercial Insurance Recruiter
Commercial Insurance Recruiting
in New York
New York is home to major insurance carriers, Lloyd's syndicates, and the largest commercial brokerage operations in the world, creating sustained demand for specialist insurance talent.
New York Market Insight: Midtown Manhattan concentrates carrier HQs, major brokerages, and specialty lines operations. The NY E&S and professional lines market is among the most technically demanding in the country.
New York Markets We Recruit In
SHG recruits commercial insurance talent across all major markets in New York — for agencies, carriers, MGAs, and wholesale brokers seeking permanent placements.
Why New York Insurance Firms Choose SHG
New York Insurance Market Knowledge
Deep understanding of New York's commercial insurance hiring environment — salary norms, talent availability, and what agencies, carriers, and MGAs are competing for.
Pre-Built Talent Pipelines
We don't start from zero when you call. Active candidate relationships across New York mean faster time-to-fill and better quality hires for permanent roles.
Permanent Placement Only
Every search in New York is direct hire. No temps, no contract-to-perm. Your hire is a full-time, permanent team member — backed by our retention guarantee.
Commercial Insurance Jobs We Recruit For in New York
SHG places commercial insurance professionals at all seniority levels — from account managers and producers to executives and directors. All placements are direct hire, permanent positions. Submit your resume to be considered for New York openings.
For New York Employers
Hire Commercial Insurance Talent in New York
Looking for a commercial lines account manager, underwriter, claims professional, or insurance executive in New York? SHG delivers permanent placements — not temps — with a retention guarantee on every search.
- Direct hire only — no temps
- Avg. 47-day time to fill
- Pre-vetted insurance candidates
- Retention guarantee included
For New York Candidates
Find a Commercial Insurance Job in New York
SHG works with top agencies, carriers, and MGAs in New York to fill permanent commercial insurance positions. If you're in commercial lines, underwriting, claims, risk management, or E&S — we want to hear from you.
- Direct hire positions only
- Agencies, carriers & MGAs
- All New York markets covered
- Confidential job search support
About SHG — Commercial Insurance Recruiters in New York
Stone Hendricks Group (SHG) is a national commercial insurance recruiting firm providing permanent placement services exclusively for the insurance industry. We serve New York agencies, insurance carriers, MGAs, and wholesale brokers with specialist commercial insurance recruiting across commercial lines, P&C, underwriting, claims, risk management, and E&S / surplus lines.
Unlike generalist staffing firms, SHG works exclusively in commercial insurance — meaning our candidate pipelines, market knowledge, and hiring process are purpose-built for insurance organizations. Every placement is direct hire and permanent, backed by our industry-leading retention guarantee.
Sectors & Roles We Recruit in New York
Commercial Lines AM Recruiter
Insurance Producer Recruiter
NY Underwriter Recruiter
Claims Adjuster Recruiter
Risk Manager Recruiter
E&S Surplus Lines Recruiter
Insurance Executive Search
P&C Insurance Recruiter
MGA Talent Placement
Wholesale Broker Recruiter
What are commercial insurance professionals earning in New York?
Download the free 2026 Commercial Insurance Salary Guide for benchmarks by role and market.